Florida Property Insurance Claim Mediation and Where to Get Help

By · Last updated

Short answer: If you disagree with your insurer about a residential property claim of $500 or more beyond your deductible, you can request free state mediation through the Florida Department of Financial Services; the insurer pays the mediator. Mediation is nonbinding, and the DFS consumer helpline (1-877-693-5236) can help before you get there.

If you disagree with how your insurer handled a claim, Florida offers help that does not require a lawyer, including a free consumer helpline and a state-run mediation program the insurer pays for. This guide explains when you can use mediation, how it works, what it costs, and how it compares with appraisal and other options, based on the Florida Department of Financial Services (DFS) and section 627.7015 of the Florida Statutes.

The claim timeline to expect

For the statutes behind these timelines, see our guide to filing a hurricane claim.

Step one: free help from DFS

Before you pay anyone, DFS's Division of Consumer Services says it will advocate on your behalf at no charge. You can submit an insurance concern online or call the Consumer Helpline at 1-877-MY-FL-CFO (1-877-693-5236). DFS's guide says it investigates submissions and lists what to have ready (see below). It can help only with policies purchased in Florida.

How residential property mediation works

Mediation is an informal conference between you and your insurer, led by a certified, neutral mediator assigned through DFS. It is designed to settle disputes before appraisal or a lawsuit.

Is my claim eligible?

Who can request it

The policyholder, a third party holding an assignment of benefits, or the insurer. An insurer is not required to participate in mediation requested by an assignee. You can request mediation online through DFS or with form DFS-I0-2082.

What happens next

Cost

DFS says the insurance company pays the entire cost of the mediation ($350). If you fail to appear and want to reschedule, you must pay the $350 rescheduled conference cost first. If the insurer fails to appear without good cause, section 627.7015 says it must pay your actual cash expenses for attending, and an insurer representative without authority to settle the full value of the claim counts as a failure to appear.

The outcome

Mediation is non-binding: neither side has to accept a settlement. If you do reach a written settlement, you have 3 business days to rescind it, as long as you have not cashed the settlement check and you notify the company. Statements made in mediation are treated as settlement negotiations.

Example

After a hurricane, a homeowner's contractor estimates $38,000 to repair a roof and interior ceilings. The insurer pays $21,000 after the hurricane deductible and says the ceiling stains are old damage. The disputed amount is well over $500 after the deductible and involves both cause and amount, so the homeowner requests DFS mediation, brings the contractor and before-and-after photos, and the parties settle at $30,500. The homeowner takes the 3-day rescission window to review the written settlement before cashing the check. (Illustrative example only.)

Sinkhole claims: neutral evaluation

For disputed sinkhole claims, DFS runs a separate neutral evaluation program, with a certified neutral evaluator rather than a mediator. Requests are made through the same DFS mediation page.

Other options if mediation does not resolve it

  1. Appraisal. If your policy has an appraisal clause, DFS says you may invoke it after the insurer's day-60 determination. Appraisal is a policy-based process for resolving disagreements over the amount of loss; your policy sets how appraisers are chosen and who pays their fees, so read it before invoking it.
  2. Public adjuster. A licensed public adjuster can handle the claim for a fee, which section 626.854 caps (generally 10 percent for claims from a declared state of emergency in the first year, 20 percent otherwise).
  3. Attorney. For large or complex disputes, a Florida attorney can explain presuit notice requirements and your rights. Ask about fees up front.

What to have ready when you contact DFS

Deadlines to remember

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to accept what the mediator suggests?

No. Mediation is non-binding. The mediator helps both sides negotiate but does not decide the claim.

Can my insurer force me into mediation?

The insurer can request mediation, but section 627.7015(2) says if it has not paid or denied the claim (or elected reinspection) within 90 days after notice of the loss, it may not require mediation.

Does mediation stop my deadlines?

Do not assume so. Keep track of policy and statutory deadlines while mediation is pending and ask an attorney if a deadline is close.

General information, not legal advice. If your claim is large or complicated, consider speaking with a licensed Florida attorney or public adjuster.

Sources

Keep reading

Try the free calculators